Judaism has sometimes been called a “culture of argument.” It is the only religious literature known to me whose key texts – the Hebrew Bible, Midrash, Mishnah, Talmud, the codes of Jewish law, and the compendia of biblical interpretation – are anthologies of arguments. That is the glory of Judaism. The Divine Presence is to be found not in this voice as against that, but in the totality of the conversation. In an argument for the sake of truth, both sides win, for each is willing to listen to the views of its opponents, and is thereby enlarged. In argument as the collaborative pursuit of truth, the participants use reason, logic, shared texts, and shared reverence for texts. They do not use ad hominem arguments, abuse, contempt, or disingenuous appeals to emotion. Each is willing, if refuted, to say, “I was wrong.” There is no triumphalism in victory, no anger or anguish in defeat.

Rabbi Jonathan Sacks

420 Notes/ Hide

  1. artisanalgoats reblogged this from jewishpangolin
  2. dvar-trek reblogged this from jewishpangolin
  3. jewishpangolin reblogged this from kuttithevangu
  4. gocrazydelusionstudent reblogged this from eusocia
  5. farbrente reblogged this from argon-co2
  6. eusocia reblogged this from argon-co2
  7. argon-co2 reblogged this from pipcomix
  8. immortalshapeshifter reblogged this from nerdyqueerandjewish
  9. lizziebordengirldetective reblogged this from pipcomix
  10. felis-lupus reblogged this from longlostpath
  11. longlostpath reblogged this from pipcomix
  12. iswearbyalltheflowers reblogged this from kuttithevangu
  13. v-lagopus reblogged this from windcalling
  14. 3dmouseart reblogged this from pipcomix
  15. downthepub reblogged this from books-n-bentleys
  16. yidquotes posted this
    Rabbi Jonathan Sacks